top of page

NYC Imposter.

Writer: Barbara Palmer
Barbara Palmer
13 minutes ago
3 min read

NYC Imposter.  I was born in NJ and grew up in CT.  We went to NY every weekend to visit my grandparents.  I have had friends living in Manhattan since college.  Field trips, friends’ weekends, shows, meetings, work events – I have spent a LOT of time in a city that I have never lived in.  And after all these years and all of these visits, I still feel like an imposter.  


In Manhattan, I walk down the street never knowing if I am going the right way.  I often get to the end of the block only to realize that the numbers were going up instead of down (or visa versa). I didn’t know until last week that 5th Ave is where East and West splits (do I have that right?).  I always start the visit with a bit of bravado that I can figure it out, only to feel like a fake when I try.


Recently, I was with one of my best friends who works in the city and lived there for years.  As we headed toward dinner, she confidently made a right, walked 20 yards and realized we should have gone the other way, quickly turned around and went the other way. In that moment, my imposter syndrome came into focus and dissipated.  If she, a confident New Yorker, could make a mistake, then why was I so critical of my city discombobulation?  


It all comes back to imposter syndrome:  feeling like a fraud.  We all feel less confident, ill-prepared or less equipped at some point in our careers and yet we judge ourselves for the lack of knowledge.  If you don’t do the task or job consistently or have the education or experience, why would you believe you have expertise.  And imposter syndrome is an insider’s game:  it is something you feel, not something you can see.  


So, as I walk around New York, I see a city of self-assured humans that look certain about where they are going and how to get uptown or downtown. (Very New Yorker, right?)  The pace indicates assuredness and I compare myself unfavorably.  


The same is true at work.  How often does someone speak with confidence and you feel smaller, more unsure, afraid to contradict or share a different point of view?  We naturally defer to more senior or more experienced co-workers when the situation may not be better assessed by either of those criteria.  It is easy to feel like you have nothing to say, but there are also tangible ways to overcome feeling like an imposter.


My favorites, adapted from Kyle Eschendroeder’s 21 Proven Ways to Overcome Imposter Syndrome, include:

  1. Focus on providing value.  You don’t need to know everything to share something.  Share and say what you can.


    In action: “I’m not sure I know the answer to the problem, but I do have information on this part of the question…”


  2. Being wrong doesn’t make you a fake.  Enter with curiosity, not judgement; accept that humans make mistakes.  Eschendroeder likens this to athletes and visionaries who don’t always hit it out of the park.  They approach mistakes as an opportunity toward growth.  FAIL:  First Attempt in Learning.


    In action: “What would you have done differently or how would you have approached this opportunity?”  


  3. Avoid regrets and don’t deprive us.  There is nothing worse than wishing you had said something when you had the opportunity.  Staying out of the conversation means you don’t share your point of view which is valuable.


    In action:  Ask someone to bring you into the conversation inviting you share or send a note after: “I have some additional thoughts on today’s discussion…”


  4. Nobody knows what they are doing.  Even the experts have never been in this moment in time.  Data is constantly changing which impacts decision-making and expertise.  Instead of feeling small by looking around the room, realize that you have the benefit of everything that came before.


    In action: “I know we tried this before, but what changed that might lead to a different outcome? How do [these factors] make this situation the same or unique?”


Back to me wandering around Manhattan and overcoming my feelings of inferiority.  

  • There are a lot of people who are willing to point me in the right direction. I need to look for the helpers.  

  • My not knowing how to navigate the city doesn’t make me a fake, it makes me a visitor.  

  • If I don’t put myself in a potentially uncomfortable place, I won’t experience all that the city has to offer.  


And even my friend who has always lived or worked in the city sometimes makes a left instead of a right.  


             

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Wisdom in Your InBox

Need some inspiration, funny stories and tips through your week? I'll see what I can do.

(don't worry, I hate spam and promise it won't be)

Broad Perspective Consulting

  • linkedin

(310) 913-8128

©2024 by Broad Perspective Consulting, Inc.

bottom of page